Which finger fits my butt best? Or can I have more than one? Tryfm N Posted on Oct 10, 2023 Posted in GoneWild by lil_aylori Related posts: my finger fits perfectly in my ass, but it’s not enough I love popping a finger in my butt Finger in my butt Anyone else like a finger up their butt when they cum? Or am I just weird?? (F) It all started with a finger in the butt OC: I took a finger up my butt for the first time while being fingered/fisted! I LOVED it!